Why not?
Are Our Driving Skills A Collective Effort?
EDITOR’S NOTE: There has been a lot of public discussion about the increase of people walking or riding bicycles this summer, and the apparent increase of conflicts with people in cars. I’ve been asked to address the issue and I’ve been trying to do it in one big manifesto…that isn’t happening, and so I throw out this one attempt; more will follow.
How’s Your Driving?
Most Americans believe that they are above average divers; despite the statement’s impossibility. A recent Allstate survey shows that despite a pugnaciousness about our skills behind the wheel, most of us knowingly practice dangerous driving. A few of the survey’s disconnects are, that despite 64% of American drivers rating themselves as “excellent” or “very good” drivers, the survey shows that:
- Eighty-nine percent say they’ve driven faster than the posted speed limit, and 40 percent say they’ve driven more than 20 miles per hour over the limit.
- Almost half (45 percent) say they have driven while excessively tired – to the point of almost falling asleep.
- Fifteen percent say they have driven while intoxicated, with men almost four times more likely than women to have done so (23 percent of men versus six percent of women).
- More than one-third (34 percent) have sent a text-message or email while driving, but the prevalence of the practice changes by age group.
- Seven in 10 American drivers say that as a result of being distracted while driving, they have slammed their brakes or swerved to avoid an accident, missed a traffic signal, or actually caused an accident.
- Fifty-six percent of American drivers say they have been involved in an accident, but only 28 percent of them say the accident was their own fault.
My Own Driving
I’m recovering from the “I’m above-average” complex. I believe I’ve done all of the above. I’m beginning to realize that despite having quick reflexes and good eye-sight, there is a world of distractions and nudges in the world conspiring to make driving difficult and dangerous. I’m not even talking about winter driving. An incident from a month ago has been on my mind lately that I’d like to share and is reflective of how I’ve examined interactions between modes on the streets this summer.
A month ago, while driving in downtown Traverse City, I went to make a left from Front St. onto Union St. I checked the light, green, and started my turn when just then a man walking with what I assume to be his 10-year-old son suddenly appeared in the crosswalk. In the end, I wasn’t close to hitting them, but as I revved my engine the boy’s father was certainly startled and my heart jumped. It could have been worse; if I drove something other than a go-cart pretending to be a car (Honda Fit) it certainly would have been.
As far as run-ins go on the streets, this was pretty tame. No one was hurt and I suspect no one was overly traumatized. In fact, it might have served as a useful reminder for those involved and a few observant onlookers that conflict points exists on our streets and it pays to pay attention and be considerate. However, as I ruminated on the situation, there was a lot of contributing variables to this sequence of events that I’d like to throw out there.
Contributing Variables
To begin with, I was late and annoyed that I chose to drive downtown on a busy and stifling hot Saturday afternoon. This contributed to me being blinded by my own needs and personal drama.
Then, I was turning off of a 2-lane one-way street and being closer to the left side of the road creates a blind spot in my car directly where the crosswalk began. If there was a bump-out the duo would have been more visible and once they had a green they would have been 1/3rd of the way across before I even started.
But before I could even think of going, I also had to contend with two giant trucks turning left on a red light as they obviously felt entitled to their left turn because they had waited for the entire cycle without an opportunity; entitlement tends to create dangerous situations. So, I was anxious; would I now miss my green cycle?
Then, the pedestrian himself was distracted: he was on his cell-phone and holding his son’s hand, himself engrossed in an ice cream cone; he was so distracted that he wasn’t even startled. Aiya, as the zen master said, “when crossing the road, be crossing the road.“
Those are the known contributing factors; there could be more. Despite the scare to both parties, the two movements could be considered a success. They crossed the road and I made my turn.
I tell the story because it is instructive of what happens 1000′s of times everyday in our little hamlet of Traverse City. Close calls happen all over the place and they contribute somewhat to raising the collective awareness, but there also many that go unnoticed or willfully ignored. Being aware of the multitude of circumstances is not to the loss of personal responsibility, rather to the broadening of our understanding of it. If, and I don’t even like writing it, I would have collided with father and son I would have been responsible and paid the personal consequences. Yet, to improve my awareness it would behest me to more broadly understand the dynamics at play. Namely, those being:
- Driving is stressful, be aware.
- People will be there; they are unpredictable & distracted.
- Expect delays.
- Our infrastructure is designed for speed; suppress the urge.
What other dynamics might I be missing?
* photo by doovie
Investments and Dividends in the Future of Transportation + (Weekly Chatter)
Last night’s sprints, the 16″ wheel round, at the The Third Coast Bike Festival.
Weekly Chatter
- More on this sometime soon, for now, introducing the candidates (Record Eagle)
- Safe routes to school begins in kindergarten (Messengers in Denim) and the many dividends of bicycle infrastructure (Straight) include, for one thing, the creation of more jobs compared to other transportation investment (PERI) including, more small, local businesses to serve riders (MetroMedia)

- It’s not just safety in numbers, the infrastructure that increases numbers increases safety for all users (Planetizen) –> –>
- D-Town’s urban gardens get more positive press (M.D.) as well as D-Town’s Art and Bikes mash-up (D.I.A.)
- The next important D.C. deadline->Sept. 30th: will Washington move on a comprehensive transportation bill? (Dirt) and do the logically thing and raise the gas tax. Here is one option being considered via MAP-21 (PDF) or, perhaps, we go radical and tax per mile (CBS) and provide a nudge that each mile costs (NYTimes). Either-way, something needs to be done (MyWHaT) and the Government Accountability Office recommends a performance based, rate of return method for funding (GAO)
Retweets
- RT (chinzeDPT)@RecordEagle Just thought the tone of the article was rather pessimistic. Words like “impossible” and “maybe” tend to promote apathy….disagree that traffic calming on #TCDivSt is “nigh on impossible.” Just needs enough citizen support and anything can happen
- RT (BikePortland) Learned last night that due to @aashtospeaks regs, ODOT designs roads for cars at 10 mph OVER the speed limit. Deadly by design.
- MT (ccoletta) ”It’s not just about the winners:”… What does it do for the entire community?
- RT (dan_munz )The debt ceiling was not voting to spend money you don’t have. It was voting to spend money you voted to spend.
- RT (pulmyears) USA should invade the USA and win the hearts & minds of the population by building roads, bridges & putting locals to work.
To Wrap
Car and Driver: The End of the Ever Expanding Highway is Near
Graphic Friday
“The inevitable conclusion is that we cannot possibly build enough roads to satisfy demand, so we must consider alternative transportation systems.“ ~ From Car & Driver’s July feature titled, The State of the Union’s Roads: What’s happening to our playground? The American highway is broken. And broke
Car & Driver’s main concern: our deteriorating highways/roadways and the cost to build and maintain them. In addition to funding sources like the inadequate gas tax, the main question is whether it is worth it with an ever-growing urban population to continue to expand, encourage and subsidize car-centric sprawl. It’s clear that we need to have a rationale discussion about more economically sustainable and conservative ways to invest our transportation dollars considering traditional roads are like cars themselves: the moment you drive them off of the lot, they decline in their value. If we do this honestly, there won’t be an alternative transportation system; there will be a true, comprehensive transportation system that isn’t so one-dimensional.
_
TC Bike Festival Begins Tomorrow
Announcement
Ready for another festival Traverse City? Here’s a quick shout out to the Third Coast Bicycle Festival. Below is a screen grab of the schedule with events beginning tomorrow morning and at Friday Night Live on Front St. downtown (skills demo, bike rodeo and Cherry-Roubaix gut busting sprints). The Record Eagle has nice coverage of the charity ride on Saturday morning which is followed by the criterium through Old Town (The Ticker). Next week is full of ambitious riding events, but also more accessible ones like Two Wheel Tuesday, the Seersucker Ride and a film night on Thursday.
Last I heard they were also looking for more volunteers. If interested, send them your contact info.
They have a pretty lazy Twitter feed, but you can follow it at TCBikeFest for any updates.
Park It Here, There, Where-ever…Jimmy John’s Parking Failure
Park It (Where?)

__

Photo sent in by JB
In the new series on bicycle parking at area businesses, we have the first poor and ugly-a zero on the matrix-ouch. Jimmy John’s at the strip mall on Front St. has absolutely nothing in the way of bicycle parking. There isn’t even a pole near-by, let alone a bicycle rack.
In their defense, the entire strip mall is under the same condition. My guess, to make a change a request to the property owner needs to occur. Anyone know who that might be? The City’s tax parcel map reveals it to be the Shaw Investment Co. and a quick perusal of the web reveals little information.
My suggestion for the owner, as there is little space not devoted to cars here, use a parking spot in front of the Thai Cafe (next door) for on street/parking lot bike rack. Or, a creative solution might be something less than perfect, but something, like they did at a Jimmy John’s in Grand Rapids shown in the picture to the right.
Again, below is a matrix for evaluating bicycle parking at businesses. Eventually, I’ll create a simple request form for people on bicycles to leave with businesses in need of bicycle parking. For now, we judge. And at Jimmy John’s, park at your own risk…luckily, they serve the fastest sandwich I’ve ever seen.
_
Related articles
- San Francisco Bike Parking Law: City May Require Businesses To Allow Bikes Inside (huffingtonpost.com)
- Bicycle Parking Lots (whatthedutch.wordpress.com)
Mobi Comes to Clinch Park Beach
Go Team!
Mobi-Mats come to Clinch Park
It was noticed over the weekend that a part of the Bayfront Plan from 2010 was quietly implemented sometime last week: Clinch Park Beach now has a Mobi-Mat installed leading from the west side of the beach down to the water. Mobi-Mats are mobile walkways that create comfortable, convenient access over the unstable beach sand. The mobile walkways were made possible through funding efforts by Disability Network, Northern Michigan.
In a letter to the parks and recreation commission, the networks resource development manager, Annie Campbell, explained the effort:
“Most people equate disability with limitations. But it’s our mission at Disability Network to change the perceptions and realities that prevent people with disabilities from sharing in the community. With the help of local supporters, we have raised approximately $10,000 toward the purchase of mobility mats to be used on the Traverse City’s beaches. Our hope is to enhance our community’s accessibility for individuals while creating a welcoming, inclusive community.“
While I was there I spoke with a woman using a leg-scooter and in a leg cast who was returning from the water using the mat. She said that since her injury she has gained appreciation for what others contend with and that the Mobi-Mats speak well for Traverse City. “I’m from California,” she said. “It’d be a shame to come to Traverse City, Michigan and not be able to touch Lake Michigan. Now I can.”
Her partner, who wasn’t wearing a leg cast, said he likes how he now can get off the beach without sand on his feet.
The mats have already been installed at the State Park beach and are planned for other TC beaches. This is a big step towards meeting the goals of universal access along the bayfront. And to think, some people opposed the inclusion of these. Really?…take a walk.
You can learn about the work of the Disability Network by viewing a recent episode of Investigating Resilience titled: The Disabled Are Not Invisible
.
Head-nod Approval from City Commission for #TCDivSt Recommendations
A Micro-Crank
Division Street
“Crossing Division and 14th St. is a nightmare. I don’t know if I’ll survive crossing that street two times a day.”
~ public comment by Marya Washington Tyler, who uses the intersection daily.
_
There isn’t too much to comment on from last night’s city commission study session reviewing the Division St. recommendations (posted here over the weekend). For the most part, city commissioners nodded in agreement that–”yes, Division is bad.” “Yes, something needs to be done.” “Yeah, someone will get to it.“
They received the recommendations without perceivable commitment, then listened to public comment in support of the recommendations & prompt action, and then they promised to revisit it in the near future. Fair enough, this isn’t exciting stuff (for some) and it was just a lowly study session. However, what wasn’t said was telling. I didn’t hear one of them say they would pick up where Mayor Chris Bzdok will leave off and champion this project. Most of the commissioners appeared to looking around the room as if there was someone else responsible. I walked way with the impression that they see their role as watchdogs to make sure the Division St. project doesn’t get out of hand or include items they personally find objectionable.
(That comment may sting and doesn’t apply equally to all commissioners. I remind commissioners they are encouraged to contribute to this blog at anytime, either in comment or guest post. Or, meet with me anytime to clarify your position.)
Message to Commissioners: If Not You, Who?

I remind the commissioners, the Division Street steering committee, itself convened by the City Manager, consisted of citizen volunteers from all over the city and region, as well as representatives and city partners from area businesses, organizations, and governmental units. MDOT and the Grand Traverse County Road Commission were deeply involved. At its epic, there were over 40 people involved. The recommendations are well thought out and have broad appeal and application. And, they are only the start.
There are many reasons to do nothing on Division St; it is such a poor place for human beings that for longtime residents of the city, imagining something different is near impossible, let alone taking steps to change it. What we need now is a strong and responsive city commission to start moving on these recommendations as well as the modeling produced in 2010. Some of them will be more difficult than others, some of them won’t be achievable or even have noticeable effect, however, many of them are just waiting for the political will to carry out. For example, planting trees strategically along the tree-lawn can happen this fall or early spring 2012.
It’s not money at issue, it is interest, political will and leadership.
I echo what co-chair of the steering committee, Fred Schaafsma, ended his comments to the commissioners with last night, “I put this in your hands.” The responsibility is yours, city commissioners.
And, realistically, it is also ours. These recommendations are also now in the hands of the citizenry who will need to continue to provide the external energy to remind City staff and commission that these demands requests are not going away. We need to remind, continually and from every corner, that we want what the steering committee drafted as its objective:
To change the character of Division Street to create a City Street that is:
- safer for motorists, bicyclists, and pedestrians to share, travel along, and to cross
- better fits the context of the city and its neighborhoods
- unites the east and west sides of the street, and
- creates the environment and driver behavior to insure that traffic speeds will be reduced to 30-mph. This must be a demonstrable requirement.
Another Version Of The Rock And Roll Video
Video Tuesday
by BuckyStudios
Many readers sent me the original “rock and roll” video-thank you.
For some reason, I never re-posted it. Now I know why..I like this version.
Guilty of Riding a Bicycle in the Street, Punished by Death
Well Put WTF?
He was riding his bicycle in the street. That seems to have contributed to this. It’s still under investigation.”
~ Sgt. Joseph Dutoi after death from crash in Saginaw

Google Street View of crash site.
An unbelievably disgusting response.
Let me offer up a more suitable response for Sgt. Dutoi:
“The fact that the driver was driving a 3.2 ton vehicle around 30-mph seems to have contributed to this. There is no other explanation for the life-ending injuries. The degree of responsibility by the driver is still under investigation.“
And, projecting into the situation a little, perhaps a follow-up statement expressing:
“We need people to slow down in residential sections and, where appropriate, drop below the speed limit when pedestrians and bicyclists present. We also need to work with the city in improving the context of this street to produce the behavior that is better for the residents here, including aiming to reduce the speed limit from 30-mph to 25, or even 20, if we want to avoid this from happening again.”
Of course, I’m dreaming.
Speaking to the local ABC affiliate, a resident from this area, Alicia Vollmer, exhibited the right attitude in response to this crash. “This ain’t a highway, you know, it’s the city,” she told reporters.
Well put.
_
Consider sending a comment to the Saginaw Police department regarding bicyclists rights to the road and residents rights to public safety and high quality of life. They have a contact form at the bottom of their info page Contact Saginaw Police or you may call with a complaint to (989) 399-1311.
* If you liked to see the comment I submitted, send me a message.
For Your Review: Division Street Recommendations
EDITOR’S NOTE: This post originally posted on Aug. 7, 2011. (Little, if anything, has been done at the City to move it forward.)
Tomorrow night’s City Commission study session will discuss the following recommendations from the Division Street steering committee. The group consisted of volunteers concerned about Traverse City’s Division Street corridor. It included citizens from across the city as well as representatives from area businesses, organizations, and governmental units. It was well represented by the diversity of the City. The City also has completed modeling for the modern roundabout scenarios with positive results.
















Reader's Comments